Open Source Gaming Review: Linux Gamers Live DVD 0.9.2 (Page 1 of 1)
Written by
Steve Lake
Posted on: Jul 02, 2007 at 03:05pm
Section:
Gaming
Printer Friendly Version
Legacy URL
Being an avid gamer who loves Linux, I felt that it would be a good idea to go try out the
new Linux-Gamers.net live dvd. This is a live dvd built on Arch Linux and designed with
one purpose in mind. Gaming. No desktop apps, no office suites, no web browsers. Nope,
nothing but gaming. So I popped the DVD into my test machine and booted it. Immediately
after initial boot I was greeted by a screen that notified me that it had detected my
Nvidia video card and that no proprietary driver would be installed, although one would be
available later for install should I want to use it. There’s a quick legal
explanation of why this is so and goes on to explain about some open source projects that
are working to provide free Open Source drivers for Nvidia and ATI video cards since
neither company will provide this themselves. There’s also a short blurb to the Linux
development and enthusiast communities of Linux on why they did this. The general claim
can be summed up like this. “If we don’t build it, they won’t come.” I
admit that’s a bit of a rewording of a famous line from the book “Field of
Dreams”, but it applies very well here.
There’s a big discussion out there between the purists who want everything open
sourced, and the realists who realize that everything can’t necessarily be open
source and that some proprietary software can and may be needed from time to time,
including drivers. So inclusion of such software, especially drivers, into a Linux
distribution is a heated issue. I for one fully support open source everything in Linux.
That obviously can’t be true all the time, so I’m flexible enough to accept
proprietary software where and when nessisary, and sticking with open source software
whenever possible. But that’s a whole other debate, so I’ll leave that for
another time.
After clicking ok you’re given an EULA for your video drivers, be they Nvidia or ATI.
In my case it was Nvidia. Once you click ok, you’re asked if you agree to the terms.
After clicking yes, it was off to the races. The Nvidia driver quickly installed and
within a minute or so the system fully loaded into the desktop for the live dvd. Also, for
those who are curious, I tested this dvd on a nearly identical system that had an ATI
9600xt card in it. Even with the ATI card I had few issues. There was a bit of
artifacting and strange program behavior that’s likely due to the ATI driver, but
other than that it worked great. Now once you’re booted completely into the live cd,
the closest thing you get to a typical gui interface is a taskbar with a bunch of quick
launch icons. The games that are included on this disk are:
- Blobby2
- bzFlag
- Foobillard
- GL-117
- Glest
- Neverball
- Nexuiz
- Sauerbraten
- Torcs
- Tremulous
- UFO:AI
- Wesnoth
- Warsow
- Warzone 2100
- World of Padman
The original version of the live dvd included “Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory”
and “True Combat: Elite”, a mod of WolfET. Both have since been removed due to
licensing issues and an apparent hissy fit by the creators of WolfET over the inclusion of
the game on the live dvd. But that’s moot argument at this point given the wide range
of other games on this live dvd. Now, if you right click on the desktop you will be
presented with a short menu that lists all the games in alphabetical order. You can also
change your monitor resolution from this menu, open Xterm, shut down the machine or
save/load previous configuration changes from a USB stick, which is good considering that
any changes you make won’t be saved when you reboot since this is a live dvd. The
Xterm does provide you with a limited amount of Linux functionality that should give
anyone needing to make some configuration changes or troubleshoot a problem with their
system ample ability to do so. It’s also interesting to do a process list and see
what’s running.
Keeping to the kiss principle, everything about the live dvd is more or less point and
click. So while the dvd won’t show off the power of Linux, it does make it simple to
demonstrate the gaming potential of Linux. After getting this far without incident, it was
only fitting to give each of the games a spin and see how they did. This is important
considering that a typical live dvd tends to vary in some ways from a live system.
Here’s a general overview of how each game performed.
Blobby2
The game loaded well and got you started, but after that it had a lot of control issues
which made playing the game nearly impossible. There also seemed to be hang-ups that
appeared to just suspend gameplay for no apparent reason leaving the ball hanging in the
air with no way to get it back down. A quick dive into the options to make some
adjustments fixed this, but it wasn’t immediately apparent that this was required in
advance in order to play the game properly in single player mode. Not a big deal for
me, but definately a strike from the point of view of a less savy computer user.
bzFlag
For a simple tank game that operated using a simple capture the flag type of gameplay, it
performed very well. That’s really not all that surprising though considering the
game has been around since the early 90’s in one form or another and has grown into
quite a fun game despite its simplistic graphics. While I couldn’t tell what the
frame rates were, they appeared to be pretty high given the zero evidence of lag in the
game.
Foo Billard
This is a simple 3D pool game done in the old billiards style with about late 90’s
level 3d graphics. Given the light weight nature of the game it played fast and flawless.
The only glitch I found is that on ATI cards it seems to have trouble properly rendering
the balls, so you can’t tell which is solid and which is stripe, and that can get
frustrating at times.
gl-117
gl-117 is a simple 3D combat fighter sim done in a mid to late 90’s graphics and
gameplay style.. Overall load times for the main screen and subsequent game sessions is
decent, although not spectacular. I also saw a varying amounts of lag. One other thing
that really stood out was that it had no sound and there were control issues. I don’t
know if that’s the fault of the game or not, but I hadn’t had either of these
issues before trying this game.
Glest
Glest is a 3d fantasy strategy game done in a style resembling Starcraft or Warcraft.
Initial load into the menu screen was fast, but load times into a game were painfully
long. Well over 5-8 minutes for me, which is saying a lot considering that most of the
other big offenders for load times took barely over two. I also ran into several
spontaneous reboots and complete crashes to the desktop while trying to play this game. So
I’m not quite sure what’s up with that, but there’s definitely some issues
with this game operating on the live dvd..
Neverball
If you’ve ever played with one of those rolling marble puzzle games, you’d love
Neverball. It’s more or less a 3d version of those marble puzzle games and is tons of
fun. It’s also a very touchy game. It becomes incredibly easy to over-tilt the table
and have your ball screaming off in directions you never intended. Gameplay was smooth and
while I couldn’t get sound working, the rest was great and the game was fun.
Nexuiz
This quake 1 style shooter (see our
review of it here) works surprisingly (or unsurprisingly depending on your viewpoint)
well in the live cd. Gameplay was smooth and load times were decent. It had a few sound
issues, but overall gameplay wasn’t that bad.
Sauerbraten
This is another quake 1 style shooter, done with a touch of wolfenstein flavor. There were
some really bad stability, lag and sound issues with this game. More so than what would
appear in a full install. Sure, the game itself has a few bugs, but they don't appear much
in a full install. However, they were very blatantly apparent here on the live cd.
So much so that it made the game nearly unplayable in more ways than I can count.
Torcs
This is a classic style PC racing game done in the classic rally derby style. I could
comment on gameplay, if I could have played any games that is. The game was so flakey it
was unplayable. That is, when it didn’t crash to the desktop repeatedly.
Tremulous
This is a classic team vs team deathmatch style game with the added twist of capture the
flag, but without the flag. Gameplay was smooth, load times were good, and the game was
very stable.
UFC: Alien Invasion
I’m not really sure what genre to slide this game into, other than maybe an offbeat
RTS. It loaded very, very fast, was solid as a rock, and gameplay load times were nearly
non-existent. I have no real complaints with this one at all.
Wesnoth
This is a simple turn based RPG done in the old Zelda style of gameplay. While Zelda
wasn’t turn based, you will very much feel like you’re in an old Zelda game. The
cutscenes are a bit cheesy, and load times are on the poor side, but otherwise it’s
not that bad overall, and definitely quite playable. The random lag bothered me the most
about it. And when it’d lag, it’d really, really lag.
Warsow
This is a Quake 3 Arena deathmatch style FPS done in a cell shaded style that gives it an
almost crazy, cartoony style that gives it a sort of Anime/Japanese game feel. Overall,
the game ran very smooth, very fast and while the weapons were a bit odd, I really found
no issues at all with the game. Even load times were very fast. And all this despite
having fairly modern gameplay and graphics.
Warzone 2100
One of the things that surprised me with this game is it is played in a window rather than
full screen. That really isn’t bad consider that it’s an RTS, but it’s
still a bit hard to get used to right away. Sound was so-so, and had some issues, but
graphics were good and the game appeared to be fairly stable. Load times were also good.
World of Padman
This zany, loony, ever popular FPS had some rather annoying lag issues. Even navigating
menus it had some real problems with operating in a consistent manor. There were also
random volume issues with the sound and problems with sounds sticking in a looping mode.
Overall load times were pathetic compared to its fully installed live counterpart. It took
seemingly forever for just one level to load. There were also a number of strange
irregularities that occurred in the game that I’ve never seen in its live
counterpart. It was bad enough at times to make the game generally unplayable. The game
even locked up on me a couple times. The regular fully installed game is tons better and
doesn’t suffer from the same issues found here on the live cd. For more information
on this game, check out our review here.
Well, that’s a general overview of how each of the games functions and what to expect
from them on the live cd. The next thing up was to test the save and restore abilities of
the live dvd. So I right clicked, selected “Save configs on USBstick”. Initially
it took several tries for the live dvd to find my pendrive. Finally when it found it, it
backed up the configs. Not quickly, but it did back them up. Total time was about 3-5
minutes to save all the configs. It was about the same to load them back into the system.
A quick check of the pendrive afterwards found all my previously stored files intact and
an additional file titled “lg.net-live.tar.gz” which weighed in at about 338k
and contained all the configuration files for the live dvd and the games.
Overall I like this live dvd of popular free Linux games and I wish the absolute best to
the developers of the Linux-Gamers.net Live DVD and I want to encourage them to continue
their work. It’s very, very much appreciated. While it’s still got some growing
to do, and some bugs to iron out, it really has been a very enjoyable distribution to
experiment with. I especially like the idea that I can take it with me anywhere I go and
play some of my favorite Linux games, even if the system I’m playing it on
doesn’t have Linux. There’s one last thing I would want the developers to
consider for their next live dvd distribution. Since large sized pendrives (2gb and above)
are becoming fairly cheap and easy to come by, why not make a version that can be written
to and loaded from a pendrive? Since every machine has USB ports (but not
nessisarily a DVD drive) and since a pendrive tends to be a lot smaller and easier to
carry, it would be a completely acceptable way to take their live dvd to the next level.
:)
|
Average vistor rating: 3.9 out of 5 (17 total votes) | |
|
Latest Articles
Upcoming Shows and Cons
Announcements
There are no current announcements.
How often do you change distros?
Latest Releases
(courtesy of Distrowatch)
More
|
